200 Harry Potter Would You Rather Questions

Challenge your inner witch or wizard with these hard-hitting Harry Potter Would You Rather questions. They will make you consider choices you never thought you’d be faced with. Similar to how Harry, Ron, and Hermione felt in their difficult years. Become a part of their wizarding world in your mind.

1. Would you rather teach Potions while doing a handstand, or Defense Against the Dark Arts, but everyone knows you’re a Death Eater?

2. Would you rather constantly be at battle with Voldemort, or never experience an adrenaline-filled battle in your life?

3. Would you rather always get booger-flavored Bertie Bott’s Every Flavor Beans, or always miss the train to Hogwarts?

4. Would you rather have to perform magic with a broken wand for the rest of your life, or never get your letter from Hogwarts and miss out on your magical powers all together?

5. Would you rather ride a Thestral you cannot see, or ride a dragon knowing it might kill you?

6. Would you rather break into Gringotts without a noise maker, or be out late in the Hogwarts halls without an invisibility cloak?

7. Would you rather know you are a witch or wizard prior to receiving your letter to Hogwarts, or have the letter come as a complete surprise?

8. Would you rather be stuck living with the Dursleys, or have to reside in Hagrid’s beard throughout childhood?

9. Would you rather always fall off your broom when playing quidditch, or never be successful in any moves you make during the game?

10. Would you rather always forget the password to your common room, or be placed in the wrong house?

11. Would you rather be the child of a Hogwarts professor and get punished more easily, or not have any parents at all?

12. Would you rather get possessed by Tom Riddle, or have all of your friends die around you in combat?

13. Would you rather have a pet snake like Nagini, or have a flying car?

14. Would you rather eat a fainting fancy, or a puking pastille?

15. Would you rather experience the Crucio Curse, or the Densaugeo hex?

16. Would you rather have to be Draco Malfoy’s henchman, or be Hermione Granger’s assistant?

17. Would you rather Sirius was your dad, or Snape was your uncle?

18. Would you rather teach Herbology to students who want nothing to do with it, or have to impersonate professor McGonagall every time she speaks?

19. Would you rather keep the secret that Hagrid is secretly evil, or keep the secret that Voldemort is coming to attack?

20. Would you rather get sorted into a house without the sorting hat, or have the sorting hat place you in the wrong house?

21. Would you rather never be able to find platform 9¾, or be stuck in a car with Crabbe and Goyle every time you go to Hogwarts?

22. Would you rather compete in the Triwizard tournament, or be one of the loved ones tied underwater?

23. Would you rather be lost in the Forbidden Forest, or trapped inside Azkaban?

24. Would you rather not be able to take potions class, or not be able to take flying lessons?

25. Would you rather turn into a giant at night, or be a goblin during the day?

26. Would you rather have a three-headed dog as a pet, or a basilisk?

27. Would you rather have Moaning Myrtle follow you around everywhere you go, or lose your head like Nearly Headless Nick?

28. Would you rather not be able to use magic for one hour every time you tell a lie, or have your broom go out of control for every lie you’ve ever told?

29. Would you rather own a Cloak of Invisibility, or a Pensieve?

30. Would you rather drink unicorn blood, or have to eat elf toenail clippings for breakfast every day?

31. Would you rather work as a house elf with no pay, or be responsible for everything that happens at Hogwarts and be rich?

32. Would you rather travel by broom, or by flying carriage?

33. Would you rather eat gillyweed, or use the bubble head charm when swimming underwater?

34. Would you rather drink Polyjuice Potion for breakfast every morning, or eat cereal made of disgusting Bertie Bott’s Every Flavor Beans?

35. Would you rather lose all of your house’s points one time, but earn them back, or never earn a point for the house through all your years at Hogwarts?

36. Would you rather have to sneak past a dragon, or outrun a Basilisk?

37. Would you rather not survive a murder attempt from Voldermort, or have him repeatedly try to come kill you until you kill him?

38. Would you rather be attacked by Quirrell, or have Dumbledore turn on you?

39. Would you rather be killed by Voldemort, or have all your friends be killed by Voldemort?

40. Would you rather never go to the right place when travelling by Floo Powder, or always have to walk to all your destinations?

41. Would you rather be locked in a bedroom in the Dursley’s home, or be locked in a room within Hogwarts and no one knows you’re there?

42. Would you rather dress in all pink like Dolores Umbridge with hair like Snape’s, or dress in all black like Snape with hair like Dolores Umbridge?

43. Would you rather be forced to travel by centaur, or become a giant every time you needed to travel?

44. Would you rather eat nothing but puking pastilles, or fever fudge every time you wanted to do something fun with your friends?

45. Would you rather always act like Dudley when you don’t get your way, or never express your displeasure?

46. Would you rather be able to speak Parseltongue, or be able to speak to your own pet?

47. Would you rather have a snake escape when you’re at the zoo, or always know there is a dragon at the bank when you go there?

48. Would you rather have one bottle of phoenix tears you can use 20 times, or have a phoenix for its lifetime but need to take good care of it?

49. Would you rather have your wand go missing every time you mess up a spell, or be perfect at every spell you try but have everyone hate you for it?

50. Would you rather take an overload of courses and use a Time Turner to get through it, or take as few courses as possible but always miss them anyways?

51. Would you rather have Fred and George as brothers who always prank you, or have Dudley as a brother who leaves you alone?

52. Would you rather have a pig tail like Dudley, or have the bones in your arm turn to JELL-O?

53. Would you rather receive the best broom out there, or a new wand capable of strong magic for your birthday?

54. Would you rather have a pet like Hedwig, but have an evil person residing within her, or have a pet like Scabbers who is innocent?

55. Would you rather come from a long line of dark wizards, or be the first person in your family to get a letter from Hogwarts?

56. Would you rather be a wand maker like Ollivander, or break every wand you pick up?

57. Would you rather have to wear a uniform every day, even on the weekend, or always show up under dressed?

58. Would you rather always forget the textbook you need when showing up to class during first year, or always misplace your quills?

59. Would you rather have to fight Mrs. Weasley in battle, or be kidnapped by Death Eaters?

60. Would you rather have to live with Uncle Vernon, or be Lucius Malfoy’s least favorite child?

61. Would you rather cast your first Patronus in the safety of a classroom, or have to cast it on a train in front of all your peers as a Dementor wreaks havoc on everything?

62. Would you rather only be able to use magic when around other magicians, or find yourself not being able to perform magic when it’s most needed if others are around?

63. Would you rather raise a dragon from the day it hatched, or own a unicorn?

64. Would you rather fly a flying car into the Whomping Willow, or constantly have a toe peeking out from your invisibility cloak when trying to sneak around undetected?

65. Would you rather have to fight a troll every time you go to the bathroom, or have a house elf constantly following you around, never giving you any privacy?

66. Would you rather be in Slytherin but always have to sleep in the Gryffindor common room, or always be late to the dining hall and miss your meals?

67. Would you rather be disliked by Dumbledore, or loved by Voldemort?

68. Would you rather find out you’re a magical being by surviving a fall out of a window, or by surviving a murder attempt?

69. Would you rather have moving staircases all over your home, or have your home look like a castle surrounded by an enchanted forest?

70. Would you rather have to take flying lessons with the Slytherin house, or take flying lessons with someone who doesn’t know how to fly?

71. Would you rather break your wrist when learning how to fly, or have a really embarrassing fall during a Quidditch match?

72. Would you rather play quidditch every day no matter the weather, or only play during matches without any practice?

73. Would you rather own a broom that malfunctions sometimes but always listens to you, or a broom that always works perfectly but has a mind of its own?

74. Would you rather duel with Malfoy in first year, or have to take Fluffy on walks every day?

75. Would you rather drink a random potion every morning not knowing what will happen to you, or experience someone casting one Unforgivable Curse in your direction every day hoping you dodge it?

76. Would you rather have Hermione overhear you insulting her, or talk back to Snape in class and get detention?

77. Would you rather be a part of Dumbledore’s army, or have no idea there is any form of discourse happening around you?

78. Would you rather miss the Halloween feast, or have to stay at Hogwarts over Christmas?

79. Would you rather receive a sweater from Mrs. Weasley, or a lifetime supply of Every Flavor Beans?

80. Would you rather have Quirrell casting spells on your broom during a quidditch match, or be the one that has to save someone from Quirrell casting spells on their broom?

81. Would you rather become a Hogwarts prefect, or be known as someone who notoriously breaks the rules?

82. Would you rather be stuck in Filch’s body, or be in your own body but adopt Filch’s personality?

83. Would you rather have a Mirror of Erised, or a Pensieve?

84. Would you rather be bitten by a young dragon, or have to outrun an angry centaur?

85. Would you rather come across Voldemort drinking unicorn blood, or find an injured unicorn and not know how to help it?

86. Would you rather be under a full body bind curse every night when going to bed, or be under a muting spell during the day?

87. Would you rather get in trouble for performing magic while not in school, or continuously mis-perform magic when at school?

88. Would you rather get trapped in a Devil’s snare when trying to do good, or experience nothing but kind, well-meaning, and helpful people on your quest to do something bad?

89. Would you rather be trapped in a room of flying keys, or have to sacrifice yourself in a game of chess?

90. Would you rather have your mail stolen by Dobby all summer while locked up on Privet drive, or have to spend the summer in the hospital wing?

91. Would you rather receive a warning letter from the Ministry of Magic you didn’t do, or have someone else be blamed for committing magic when it was actually you?

92. Would you rather end up in Knockturn Alley every time you want to go to Diagon Alley, or be completely oblivious to the dark wizards around you?

93. Would you rather travel with Floo Powder, or with a flying car?

94. Would you rather witness Lucius Malfoy and Arthur Weasley in a fight, or find a great deal on new dress robes?

95. Would you rather be Harry and share your wealth with your friends, or be Ron and never make mention to your lack of money?

96. Would you rather fight a Basilisk in the Chamber of Secrets, or accidentally open the Chamber and not tell anyone until it’s too late?

97. Would you rather have classes disturbed by Pixies, or look out the window to see Hagrid fighting with a dragon and not be allowed to say anything?

98. Would you rather have your pet be petrified in the halls of Hogwarts, or have your favorite professor be petrified?

99. Would you rather be caught breaking into Dumbledore’s office, or have your Polyjuice potion wear off while breaking into the Slytherin common room?

100. Would you rather drink a Polyjuice potion and transform into a cat by mistake, or have others constantly drinking Polyjuice potion and impersonating you?

101. Would you rather have werewolves be allowed to have jobs, or be a werewolf yourself?

102. Would you rather come across a colony of Acromantulas, or a dragon guarding her recently laid eggs?

103. Would you rather win the house cup knowing you had bribed the professors to give you more points, or lose the house cup knowing another house had bribed the professors to give them points?

104. Would you rather be a house elf who doesn’t get paid to work, or be a house elf who has to work 24/7 to get paid?

105. Would you rather escape from Azkaban and need to be a fugitive, or be locked up despite being innocent and stay for your entire sentence?

106. Would you rather have all the best Quidditch gear and suck at the game, or have second hand equipment but be an amazing player?

107. Would you rather have to face a Boggart, or an angry Hippogriff?

108. Would you rather take a class trip to Hogsmeade, or be allowed to go home one week early at the end of the term?

109. Would you rather have a Marauder’s Map that is always wrong, or have a Portkey that always took you to the wrong location?

110. Would you rather be the smartest student in all your classes, but nobody liked you, or have the poorest grades and the most friends?

111. Would you rather receive a Howler from your mother during dinner, or have a Remembrall that is always shining red?

112. Would you rather do an interview with Rita Skeeter, or never have anything significant you do be documented?

113. Would you rather receive a flying motorbike like Hagrid’s, or a flying car that may experience technical difficulties at times?

114. Would you rather have to sign all documents with a Blood Quill, or have a lifetime supply of Spellotape?

115. Would you rather always travel by the Knight bus, or by broomstick?

116. Would you rather have to eat U-No-Poo every day except on the weekends, or have to eat Ton-Tongue Toffees on weekends?

117. Would you rather have been thought to be a squib by your family, or constantly have other students making fun of you for being a Mudblood?

118. Would you rather go to the restricted section of the library, or to the third floor if you knew that both were strictly off limits?

119. Would you rather be a ghost in Hogwarts, or be a famous wizard on a playing card and always have to stay in the frame?

120. Would you rather use a Patronus to save yourself from Dementors, or a Time Turner?

121. Would you rather be the person who works the Honeydukes Express on the Hogwarts express, or be a potions professor?

122. Would you rather be expelled from Hogwarts, or only be allowed to stay there as the groundskeeper?

123. Would you rather have to tame Merpeople, or a Grindylow?

124. Would you rather have to tell your anti-magic parents that you are a wizard, or never utilize your magical powers and go to a regular school?

125. Would you rather have the same friends all through your school years, or make new friends every single year?

126. Would you rather have a date to the ball, or go alone?

127. Would you rather go on a quest to destroy all horcruxes, or set out to free all of the house elves?

128. Would you rather save someone from being attacked by Nagini, or be possessed by Nagini to attack others and not be free until you do?

129. Would you rather be stuck in a train with hundreds of Dementors, or have all your professors be Death Eaters?

130. Would you rather be locked up in Azkaban with all your friends, or be held hostage in Hogwarts all alone?

131. Would you rather be kidnapped by the flying car, or have your pet turn out to be a disguise for an evil wizard?

132. Would you rather never go home for all your years at Hogwarts, or go home every weekend?

133. Would you rather be the conductor of the Hogwarts express, or be the groundskeeper of Hogwarts?

134. Would you rather study Occlumency, or be a Legilimens?

135. Would you rather have a Valentines date in Hogsmeade, or go on an adventure with your date?

136. Would you rather own Weasley’s Wizard Wheezes, or go to the Burrow every evening?

137. Would you rather grow up in Hagrid’s shed, or with the Dursleys?

138. Would you rather be the only non-magical child in a family of witches and wizards, or have all your children have magical capabilities?

139. Would you rather get a new wand every year, or have the same wand throughout your entire life?

140. Would you rather be a famous hero, or be one of their sidekicks who helps then overcome all of their difficulties?

141. Would you rather be an evil wizard with a clan of dark wizards hoping to help you take over the wizarding world, or be a secret spy, infiltrating the group in hopes of exposing them?

142. Would you rather only have to write the OWLs, or only have to write the NEWTs?

143. Would you rather become a Death Eater against your will, or have an Unbreakable Vow with a Death Eater?

144. Would you rather be Minister of Magic, or be the Muggle Prime Minister during the second wizarding war?

145. Would you rather have a pygmy puff as a pet, or know that someone evil was residing within your pet?

146. Would you rather be a seeker, or a keeper when playing Quidditch?

147. Would you rather never see a troll in your life, or have it present a gift to you if you solved its riddle?

148. Would you rather lose your magical powers after finishing at Hogwarts, or never get the opportunity to perform magic at all?

149. Would you rather all your siblings had magical powers except for you, or be the only sibling with magical powers?

150. Would you rather drink nothing but butterbeer, or never be able to drink your favorite drink?

151. Would you rather eat only candies from Fred and George’s shop, or never have any useful candies on hand when you need them?

152. Would you rather think magic is a myth despite showing signs of magical capabilities, or believe in magic with all your being while possessing no magic capabilities?

153. Would you rather have to get through a Triwizard tournament every other year to maintain your magical powers, or have them slowly fade year-after-year and vanish when you turn 30.

154. Would you rather experience the effect of the jelly bones hex (Ossio Dispersimus) once a day, or have your bone break and need someone else to cast a spell on it once a week to fix it?

155. Would you rather have hair that changes color everyday with no way to stop it, or never be able to improve your looks using magic?

156. Would you rather have a pig tail like Dudley, without being able to remove it, or have a half-broken wand in an umbrella like Hagrid?

157. Would you rather specialize in the study of potions, or the study of herbology?

158. Would you rather be a late transfer to Hogwarts, or start in first year but then be kicked out halfway through?

159. Would you rather eat treacle tarts for the rest of your life, or only eat chocolate frogs?

160. Would you rather never be able to buy anything off the Hogwarts cart, or spend all your money for the year on the Hogwarts express to school?

161. Would you rather see Thestrals everywhere you go, or have Devil’s Snare growing in every dark corner of your home?

162. Would you rather never get new dress robes despite growing bigger, or always have to wear oversized dress robes?

163. Would you rather be best friends with Cho Chang, or Fleur DeLacour, instead of Hermione?

164. Would you rather be trapped in the Slytherin common room, or in Hagrid’s hut?

165. Would you rather explore the Forbidden Forest, or explore the Great Lake on the back of a giant squid?

166. Would you rather become Dobby, or Lucius Malfoy?

167. Would you rather be a Death Eater from birth, or have to convert to one later in life?

168. Would you rather find out one of your parents is a Death Eater, or be a muggle?

169. Would you rather find out your dog is a Horcrux, or get married to Lord Voldemort?

170. Would you rather experience Hogwarts without magical powers, or have to complete regular school using magic without getting caught?

171. Would you rather have hair like Snape’s, or be able to turn into an animal but have no control of it?

172. Would you rather have a snowball fight with bewitched snowballs, or never see snow at all?

173. Would you rather be a part of Dumbledore’s army, or work for the Ministry of Magic when you graduate?

174. Would you rather be poor but surrounded by a loving family, or be rich and all alone?

175. Would you rather work at Gringotts, or be a dragon tamer?

176. Would you rather learn all the spells but be a master of none, or know only a few spells but know them perfectly?

177. Would you rather be a prefect for your house, or be known as the class troublemaker?

178. Would you rather inhabit Peeve’s body, or Filch’s for one week?

179. Would you rather have access to a Vanishing Cabinet, or a Pensieve?

180. Would you rather be a Hogwarts’ ghost, or get a job as a professor after school and never leave?

181. Would you rather go to Hogwarts undercover, looking to spread evil, or spend your entire time at Hogwarts protecting everyone else from evil?

182. Would you rather be the child of Hagrid, or of Professor McGonagall?

183. Would you rather travel abroad to train dragons after school, or go straight into a boring job you don’t really enjoy?

184. Would you rather save Molly Weasley, or Hermione Granger during a battle?

185. Would you rather have James Potter come back to life, or Sirius Black?

186. Would you rather sacrifice Ron for Fred, or save both Tonks and Lupin but sacrifice Hagrid?

187. Would you rather use a spell to wash your dishes all the time, meaning you couldn’t have Muggles in your home, or always have to wash dishes by hand the second you make one dirty?

188. Would you rather get a new broomstick every time one is released, or keep your first broomstick that has sentimental values?

189. Would you rather have the Elder Wand, or the Resurrection Stone?

190. Would you rather have someone stick their wand up your nose when duelling, or always have to cast your spells off mirrors, not directly at your opponent?

191. Would you rather have a wizard’s duel every morning when you awake, or have to have one every night before you can go to bed?

192. Would you rather have a magical eye like Mad Eye Moody, or be a gifted Occlumens?

193. Would you rather be smarter than Hermione Granger, or be Dumbledore’s child?

194. Would you rather be rescued by a Centaur, or be saved by Phoenix tears?

195. Would you rather switch bodies with Fluffy, or with Fawkes?

196. Would you rather free Dobby with a sock, or have Dobby be your own House Elf?

197. Would you rather use fake magic to mess with your nemesis, or use real magic to help innocent people without them knowing?

198. Would you rather help Fred and George start their magic shop on your own dime, or be the only one who could cast a Patronus on a train full of Dementors?

199. Would you rather be a famous Quidditch player, or the most successful potions master in the wizarding world?

200. Would you rather blow your least favorite aunt up like a balloon, or bring Cedric Diggory back to life?