How to Make Tzatziki Sauce Without Greek Yogurt

Jan 7

Tzatziki, a refreshing and creamy sauce, is traditionally made with Greek yogurt. However, if you're out of yogurt or prefer an alternative, there are several delicious substitutes you can use. Here's how to make tzatziki sauce without Greek yogurt, using different ingredients to achieve a similar taste and texture:

1. Using Sour Cream

Method: Substitute Greek yogurt with equal amounts of sour cream.
Taste and Texture: Sour cream provides a rich consistency and smooth texture, similar to Greek yogurt.
Seasoning: No adjustment needed; use the same seasoning as you would with yogurt.

2. Using Mayonnaise

Method: Replace Greek yogurt with mayonnaise for a richer tzatziki.
Taste Adjustment: Mayo is naturally saltier, so reduce the salt amount. Add extra lemon juice for tanginess.
Seasoning: Keep the rest of the seasonings the same as with yogurt.

3. Using Crème Fraiche

Method: Crème fraiche can replace Greek yogurt in tzatziki.
Taste and Consistency: It's slightly softer and gentler-flavored than sour cream. For more tang, add extra lemon juice.
Thickness: Crème fraiche is thinner than sour cream, resulting in a slightly thinner sauce.

4. Using Ricotta

Method: Ricotta cheese can be a suitable alternative.
Texture: If you prefer a smoother texture, add olive oil and press the ricotta gently with a fork.
Salt Content: Ricotta is saltier than yogurt, so add salt gradually.

5. Using Cream Cheese

Method: Cream cheese can serve as a delicious base for tzatziki.
Taste and Texture: It's dense and rich, so thin it with a few drops of milk. Add lemon juice for tang.
Seasoning: Cream cheese is flavorful and salty, so you might want to reduce the garlic and salt in the recipe.

These substitutes allow for flexibility and creativity when making tzatziki sauce. Each alternative offers a unique flavor profile, enabling you to customize the sauce to your taste preferences. Whether you use sour cream, mayonnaise, crème fraiche, ricotta, or cream cheese, you can still enjoy the delightful flavors of tzatziki with your favorite dishes.

Featured