Secret Menu Items at Five Guys
Five Guys is known for its juicy burgers, fresh-cut fries, and unlimited toppings, but did you know they have a secret menu packed with insane burger upgrades, fry hacks, and off-menu milkshake combos? Thanks to Five Guys’ fully customizable approach, you can create some of the best secret menu items in fast food.
Here’s your ultimate guide to Five Guys’ best secret menu items and custom order hacks!
1. The Patty Melt (Burger + Grilled Cheese Hybrid)
Love burgers and grilled cheese? Combine them into one epic sandwich!
Order a Grilled Cheese Sandwich
Ask for a beef patty inside
Optional: Add grilled onions, bacon, and extra cheese
🔥 Pro Tip: This is one of the best hidden gems on the Five Guys secret menu!
2. The Double Grilled Cheese Burger
Want to take it up a notch? Use two grilled cheese sandwiches instead of a bun!
Order two Grilled Cheese Sandwiches
Ask for a burger patty, bacon, and any toppings inside
The ultimate cheesy, buttery burger experience!
💡 It’s a messy but delicious upgrade!
3. The Burger Bowl (Low-Carb/Keto Option)
Skip the bun and get a burger in a bowl!
Order a burger with no bun
Ask for lettuce as a base and add your favorite toppings
Perfect for a low-carb, keto-friendly meal!
🔥 Want extra crunch? Ask for grilled onions and jalapeños!
4. The Well-Done Fries (Extra Crispy Secret Hack)
Five Guys’ fries are already great, but if you want them super crispy, try this hack:
Order fries “well done”
They’ll double-fry them for extra crunch!
💡 This also works with Cajun Fries for a spicy, crispy kick!
5. The Cheese Fries Hack
Five Guys doesn’t list cheese fries on the menu, but you can still get them!
Order a side of fries
Ask for a side of melted cheese
Pour the cheese over the fries for a DIY fast-food nacho experience!
🔥 Want more flavor? Add grilled onions, jalapeños, or bacon bits!
6. The BLT Cheeseburger
Take a classic BLT and add a burger patty for an amazing upgrade.
Order a BLT
Ask for a beef patty and cheese
Optional: Add grilled mushrooms or BBQ sauce for extra flavor
💡 This is one of the best Five Guys mashups ever!
7. The Sloppy Joe Five Guys Style
Love Sloppy Joes? This secret menu item mimics that iconic flavor.
Order a burger with grilled onions, ketchup, and BBQ sauce
Ask for extra grilled mushrooms and melted cheese
The result? A sweet, smoky, messy, and delicious sandwich!
🔥 Add jalapeños for an extra kick!
8. The Five Guys “Secret Sauce” Hack
There’s no official “secret sauce” at Five Guys, but you can make your own!
Ask for mayo, ketchup, and hot sauce mixed together
Adds a creamy, spicy, tangy twist to burgers or fries!
💡 Try it on a grilled cheese for extra flavor!
9. The Cajun Fries & Cheese Sauce Combo
Upgrade your Cajun Fries into something even better:
Order Cajun Fries
Ask for a side of melted cheese
Dip the fries into the cheese for a spicy, creamy flavor bomb!
🔥 Want even more heat? Add jalapeños!
10. The Five Guys Pizza Burger
Turn your burger into a pizza-style masterpiece!
Order a burger with pepperoni, extra cheese, and marinara sauce
Optional: Add grilled onions and mushrooms for even more flavor
💡 Tastes like a burger-meets-pizza hybrid!
11. The Five Guys Milkshake Hacks
Five Guys lets you customize milkshakes, so try these amazing combos:
Peanut Butter + Chocolate + Bacon = Sweet & Salty Dream
Strawberry + Oreo Crumbles = Berry Cookies & Cream
Banana + Salted Caramel = Tropical Caramel Bliss
Coffee + Chocolate + Whipped Cream = Mocha Shake
🔥 Want it extra thick? Ask for less milk!
12. The Extra Bacon Everything Hack
Did you know bacon is free when added to certain items?
Add bacon to any burger, hot dog, or even grilled cheese for zero extra charge!
Makes everything even better!
💡 Want crispy bacon? Ask for “extra well-done bacon.”
How to Order a Secret Menu Item at Five Guys
Since these aren’t official menu items, you’ll need to customize your order instead of just asking for “The Patty Melt.” Here’s how to do it right:
✅ Be polite – Some employees may not know these hacks, so be patient! ✅ Know the recipe – Explain exactly what you want step by step. ✅ Expect extra charges – Adding extra toppings or cheese may cost more. ✅ Be ready to assemble it yourself – Some items (like cheese fries) require DIY stacking.
FUnlocking Five Guys’ Secret Menu
Five Guys is already one of the most customizable fast food spots, but these secret menu hacks take it even further. Whether you’re looking for an epic burger, a fry upgrade, or a milkshake mashup, there’s something for everyone.
Next time you visit Five Guys, try one of these hidden gems—or create your own!
