Secret Menu Items at Tim Hortons

Tim Hortons is a Canadian institution, famous for its coffee, Timbits, and classic breakfast sandwiches. But did you know that there’s a whole world of secret menu items that regulars and insiders swear by? While Tim Hortons doesn’t have an official secret menu, creative customers and employees have found ways to customize orders and create unique treats that you won’t see advertised.

From next-level coffee hacks to over-the-top donut creations, here’s your guide to Tim Hortons’ best-kept secret menu items.

1. The Wayne Gretzky (9 Creams, 9 Sugars)

This legendary coffee order is named after hockey icon Wayne Gretzky’s jersey number, 99. It’s a double-double taken to the extreme, with nine creams and nine sugars—making it an ultra-sweet, super-creamy caffeine overload. If you’re daring enough to try it, be prepared for a sugar rush!

2. The Iced Capp Extreme

Tim Hortons’ Iced Capp is already a fan favorite, but ask for it to be made with chocolate milk instead of cream for a richer, milkshake-like experience. Want to go even further? Add a shot of espresso for a boosted caffeine kick or mix in a pump of caramel for extra sweetness.

3. DIY French Vanilla Cold Brew

Tim Hortons’ Cold Brew is smooth and refreshing, but if you love their classic French Vanilla flavor, you can combine the two! Simply ask for Cold Brew with French Vanilla syrup for a creamy, delicious hybrid that’s perfect for any time of day.

4. The Apple Pie Donut

Take a plain Apple Fritter, then ask for it to be warmed up and drizzled with caramel and whipped cream. The result? A warm, gooey, apple-pie-inspired treat that feels like fall in every bite.

5. The Breakfast Bagel Burger

Love Tim Hortons’ breakfast sandwiches? Upgrade your bagel sandwich by asking for two sausage patties instead of one. You can also add a hash brown inside the sandwich for a crispy twist. Some customers even swap out the bagel for a toasted English muffin for a more traditional fast-food burger feel.

6. DIY S’mores Hot Chocolate

Turn your standard hot chocolate into a s’mores-inspired treat by asking for a shot of vanilla and caramel syrup, topped with extra whipped cream and a sprinkle of chocolate or cinnamon. If they have crushed graham crackers available (sometimes used for holiday drinks), you can ask for those, too!

7. The Mocha Iced Capp

If you love both coffee and chocolate, you’ll love this secret menu gem. Ask for an Iced Capp with a shot of espresso and chocolate syrup to create a rich, mocha-flavored frozen drink that’s stronger than the standard version.

8. The Timbits Ice Cream Sandwich

This one is a DIY hack: Order a chocolate chip cookie or two donuts and a side of vanilla ice cream (if available). Cut the donuts or cookies in half and sandwich the ice cream between them. You’ve now got yourself a Tim Hortons ice cream sandwich!

9. The Honey Cruller Breakfast Sandwich

Want to turn your breakfast sandwich into a sweet and savory masterpiece? Order a classic bacon, egg, and cheese sandwich but ask for it to be made with a sliced Honey Cruller instead of a bagel or biscuit. The soft, airy donut pairs surprisingly well with the salty bacon and gooey cheese!

10. The Ultimate Double Chocolate Dream

If you love chocolate, this is the drink for you. Order a hot chocolate but ask for an added shot of espresso and a swirl of chocolate syrup. It’s the perfect mix of bold coffee and rich, creamy cocoa.

11. The Tim Hortons Secret Latte

Tim Hortons’ lattes are good, but you can make them next-level by adding a shot of French Vanilla, caramel, or hazelnut syrup. For a holiday twist, try mixing in peppermint or cinnamon syrup when available.

12. The Big Timmies Breakfast

Most Tim Hortons breakfast items come pre-assembled, but you can ask for a custom mix of your favorite ingredients. Want a bagel loaded with double bacon, egg, and cheese? No problem. Prefer a croissant sandwich stacked with sausage and extra hashbrowns? You got it!

13. DIY Donut Sundae

If you’re feeling indulgent, order a Boston Cream Donut or Chocolate Dip Donut and ask for it to be warmed up. Then, top it with whipped cream, a drizzle of chocolate sauce, and a side of ice cream (if available). This turns your standard donut into a warm, gooey, ice cream-topped sundae.

14. The Secret Menu Wrap

Tired of the same old sandwiches? Order a grilled wrap and ask for a combination of ingredients not usually paired together. Try a chicken bacon ranch wrap with extra chipotle sauce or a veggie wrap with added avocado and cheese for a fresh twist.

15. The Timbits Milkshake

Want to turn your Timbits into a drink? Order a vanilla or chocolate milkshake (or Iced Capp) and ask for a few Timbits blended into it. The best flavors to use are Birthday Cake, Chocolate Glazed, or Sour Cream Glazed. It’s like a Tim Hortons version of a Blizzard or McFlurry!

Final Thoughts: Unlocking Tim Hortons’ Best-Kept Secrets

Tim Hortons might not have an official secret menu, but with these customization hacks and creative combinations, you can take your Timmies experience to the next level. Whether you’re looking for a sugar-loaded coffee fix, a dessert-inspired donut upgrade, or a unique twist on your favorite breakfast sandwich, these off-menu items are sure to impress.

Next time you visit Tim Hortons, don’t be afraid to get creative—your barista might even have some secret menu suggestions of their own!